The Substitute
Season 6 - Episode 4Original US Air Date - February 16, 2010
Naveen Andrews...............Sayid Jarrah
Nestor Carbonell...........Richard Alpert
Henry Ian Cusick.............Desmond Hume
Emilie de Ravin..........Claire Littleton
Michael Emerson............Benjamin Linus
Jeff Fahey..................Frank Lapidus
Matthew Fox.................Jack Shephard
Jorge Garcia..........Hugo "Hurley" Reyes
Josh Holloway.........James "Sawyer" Ford
Daniel Dae Kim...............Jin-Soo Kwon
Yunjin Kim...................Sun-Hwa Kwon
Ken Leung...................Miles Straume
Evangeline Lilly..............Kate Austen
Terry O'Quinn..................John Locke
Zuleikha Robinson...................Ilana
L. Scott Caldwell.............Rose Nadler
Suzanne Krull................Lynn Karnoff
Katey Sagal.................Helen Norwood
Writer......Elizabeth Sarnoff &
.................Melinda Hsu Taylor
Director.....................Tucker Gates
With this episode Lost has actually given us some answers. Unfortunately, the answers simply raise more questions but that is of course par for the course with this show.
Los Angeles
We start with Locke arriving at his home in a handicap van. Unfortunately the wheelchair ramp does not lower completely and, after fiddling with the switch a bit, he attempts to jump his chair off the ramp anyway. He fails and winds up flat on his face on the lawn with his chair collapsed beside him. To add insult to the injury, the lawn sprinklers pick this moment to turn on. Helen comes out of the house and sees him, turning off the water and coming to his rescue.
Later, Locke is taking a bath and Helen is asking him how the seminar he attended went. Locke says it was boring. Helen then suggests that instead of the large wedding they are planning that the two of them, her parents and Locke's father should just go somewhere and have a shotgun wedding. Locke disagrees, saying she deserves a walk down the aisle.
It appears that Locke's relationship with his father is much different than it was in the original timeline. There, Helen left him after he attempted to help his father against her wishes. And, of course, it was his father who caused his injury by shoving him out of the window. The fact that Helen mentioned his father as being in the wedding implies that either his father is a different person here or that Locke has been better at lying to Helen about his and his father's relationship and activities.
The next day Locke goes to his office and is almost immediately met by Randy, his manager. Randy questions Locke a bit about the seminar he attended before confronting Locke with the fact that he knows that Locke did not go. He asks Locke what he was really doing in Australia and Locke refuses to tell him. He tells Randy to just treat the time he was gone as vacation but Randy fires him instead.
Locke packs his desk and leaves but outside finds that another vehicle has parked directly next to his and that he can't lower the wheelchair ramp from his van. He pounds on the other vehicle (a Hummer) which sets off its alarm. Hurley appears and asks what he is doing. Hurley asks why Locke didn't park in the handicapped space and Locke says he can park anywhere he wants.
Hurley introduces himself as the owner of the company and asks Locke what he does. Locke admits he was just fired. Hurley admits to not liking Randy either and offers to give Locke his job back but Locke declines. Hurley gives Locke the name of a temp agency that he also owns and tells Locke to go there.
And the parallels and changes from the original timeline continue. In the original timeline Locke had been open about his plans to go on the walkabout (and Randy had been derisive to him about it). Here it seems that Randy didn't know what Locke was planning and Locke had not shared his plans with anyone. Even Helen thought he was going to the seminar whereas in the original timeline he had told "Helen" about his plans and even tried to get her to come with him.
Also, it had been heavily implied (but never quite confirmed) in the original timeline that Hurley owned the box company that Locke worked for. Here is is directly confirmed. Also, Hurley knows Randy (who had been his manager at Mr. Cluck in the original timeline). Again, it had been speculated that Hurley got Randy the job at the box company after the Mr. Cluck's was destroyed by the meteorite. It is unknown what their relationship is here.
Locke goes to the temp agency and gets frustrated when the woman interviewing him starts asking him questions like "what kind of animal would you be?" He demands to see her supervisor, who turns out to be Rose.
Locke tries to convince her to give him a job as a construction supervisor but she tells him that she doesn't think that would work. Locke starts into his "don't tell me what I can't do" speech but Rose stops him, telling him that she has terminal cancer but that instead of fighting against it she decided to make the most of her time left. She asks Locke why they don't work together to find something he can do.
And the connections continue. Rose still has her cancer but here, since she never visited the Island, it has not gone into remission. Also, the woman who first talks to Locke and asks what animal he would be was the fake psychic that Hurley visited to try to remove the "curse" of the Numbers from him. Since Hurley considers himself to be lucky in this timeline he probably never visited her here.
The next morning Locke is going through his morning routine and comes across the business card Jack gave him. He calls the number but hangs up when the receptionist answers.
Helen asks who he was talking to and he tells her but then says he isn't going to go. She asks why and he starts to become angry and tells her that he was fired from his job. She starts to ask what is going on but is interrupted when someone arrives at the door to the house.
The person at the door turns out to be from Oceanic delivering the case of knives that they had lost. She returns to Locke, who has gone into the kitchen, and asks what is going on. He tells her to open the case, showing her the knives and tells her that he didn't go to the seminar. He had gone to Australia to go on the walkabout but they wouldn't allow him to come with them.
This answers the question from a few episodes ago; Locke was lying when he told Boone that he had gone on the walkabout.
Locke goes on to say that Helen keeps wanting him to go to doctors and therapist hoping that he would be able to walk again but that he now knows that he never will. He tells her that he doesn't want her to keep waiting for something that will never happen.
Helen tells him that she doesn't want him to walk, she just wants him. She tears up Jack's business card and they kiss.
Later, Locke is at his temporary job as a substitute teacher. After teaching a gym class and a class on the human reproductive system he goes to the faculty lounge. There, he finds someone ranting about the fact that someone took the last of the coffee without making a new pot. Locke says he prefers Earl Grey tea anyway to which the teacher responds that someone drinks a "civilized" drink.
The teacher turns around to reveal that he is Ben. Ben introduces himself as a teacher of European history and the two shake hands.
Yes, I can see Ben as a history teacher. And as a completely irrelevant aside I know his pain of people not making a new pot of coffee from my office. More directly, it does seem that Ben and Locke seem to somehow recognize each other.
Island - The Beach
Inside the base of the statue, Ben finds Iliana crying. He asks what is wrong and she calms herself down, asking what happened to the rest of her people. Ben tells her how "Locke" turned into Smokey the Monster and killed them. She then asks if "Locke" also killed Jacob and, after a slight hesitation, he says yes.
Iliana asks if Jacob was killed then where was the body. Ben says that "Locke" kicked it into the fire and it was consumed. Ilyana pulls a bag from her belt and fills it with ash from the firepit.
Not much to say here except to observe that Ben lied and told Ilana that "Locke" killed Jacob, not him. Also, Iliana seemed to know to take the ash from the firepit but it is not known what she is planning to do with it.
They go outside and find that everyone except Frank and Sun have gone to the temple. Iliana says they need to go there as well but Sun says she needs to find Jin first. Iliana tells her that Jin will be at the Temple.
They seem determined to keep Jin and Sun away from each other since we know that Jin isn't at the Temple
Sun asks about "Locke" and Iliana says that he is "recruiting". She also says that he can now only take "Locke"'s form. They start to leave but Sun insists that they need to bury Locke first.
Iliana's comment about "Locke" being forced to keep that form now implies that many of the other apparitions we have seen on the Island have been Smokey as well. It isn't clear why he is now stuck as "Locke" however. He can obviously still change into Smokey the Monster form though.
They take Locke to the beach where the other Losties are buried. After digging a grave and lowering Locke's body into it, Iliana asks if anyone has anything to say. After a moment in which everyone seems to be at a loss for words Ben steps forward and says that Locke was a true believer and a better man than he will ever be. He then says that he is sorry he killed him. Everyone looks surprised and, as they start to refill the grave, Frank comments that this was the strangest funeral he has ever seen.
Ben has admitted to everyone that he killed Locke. It is unknown how this will affect things down the road. Ben seems like a totally broken man at this point.
Island - The Jungle
We start with a scene from Smokey the Monster's point-of-view as it careens through the jungle. It stops briefly in New Otherton to look in on the house where Sawyer is staying (at which point we see its reflection in a window) before continuing into the jungle to where it finds a machete lying on the ground. Smokey morphs into "Locke" and picks up the machete.
"Locke" goes to where something wrapped in canvas is hanging from a tree. He cuts it down and unwraps it, revealing Richard.
"Locke" gives Richard some water and apologizes for beating him up. He then asks Richard if Jacob ever explained what was going on on the Island. Richard says he did not and "Locke" asks why Richard simply followed Jacob's instructions without asking questions.
They are interrupted when "Locke" suddenly sees a young, blond boy with bloody hands and arms standing some distance away. "Locke" asks Richard if he can see the boy but Richard cannot. "Locke" is distracted and wanders off, leaving Richard standing in the jungle.
Once again we get confirmation that Smokey and "Locke" are the same entity. What was Smokey looking for when it went to New Otherton; just looking to see if Sawyer (or anyone) was there? Was it looking for the machete that it used to cut Richard down.
Also, why did "Locke" beat up Richard then try to convince him to join him. Seems a bit counterproductive. Was beating up Richard something he did for the benefit of Ben and the others on the beach? What was he trying to accomplish?
Finally, who is the boy and why couldn't Richard see him? Was it Jacob? Aaron? Someone else?
"Locke" goes to New Otherton where he finds Sawyer getting drunk in his house. Sawyer seems unsurprised to see "Locke" and only says "I thought you were dead." "Locke" replies "I am."
"Locke" tells Saywer that he can answer the most important question of all; why he is on the Island. He says that he will show Sawyer if he will follow him.
Later, the two are walking through the jungle when "Locke" again sees the blond boy (this time not bloody). "Locke" discovers that Saywer can see him too and starts running after him. He trips and falls then looks up to see the boy standing before him.
The boy tells "Locke" that he "broke the rules" to which "Locke" angrily responds with Locke's tag line "Don't tell me what I can't do!" The boy leaves and "Locke" yells after him.
Meanwhile Richard, looking frightened, shows up where Sawyer has been left standing. Richard tries to convince Sawyer that he is in danger and to come with him to the temple. Sawyer comments that he has never seen Richard frightened before but refuses to come with him. They hear "Locke" returning and Richard flees. "Locke" asks Saywer who he was talking too and Saywer claims no one was there.
They continue on their way for a while then Sawyer stops and asks "Locke" if he ever read Of Mice and Men. "Locke" says he has not and Saywer says that it was is favorite book. He pulls his gun and points it at "Locke"'s head; "Locke" simply looks amused at this.
Sawyer says that he knows "Locke" is not really Locke because Locke was always scared, though he tried to pretend that he was not. "Locke" does not deny this but continues to tell Saywer that he will answer his questions when they get to where they are going.
They arrive at a cliff on the edge of the ocean and climb down a series of unstable wooden and rope ladders. One of the rope ladders breaks and Sawyer nearly falls but "Locke" saves him. The ladders lead to a cave slightly above the water's edge.
Inside there is a desk on which sits a balance scale holding a black stone and a white stone. "Locke" picks up the white stone and throws it into the ocean. Sawyer asks what that was all about and "Locke" responds "Inside joke".
Once again we see the black and white stones. All the way back in the very first episode, long before we heard about Jacob or "Locke", Walt found Locke with a backgammon game on the beach. Locke told him that it was a very old game and that there were "two sides; one is white, one is black".
A few episodes later Jack, Kate and the others find the two bodies they call "Adam" and "Eve" in the cave. One of them had a pouch in their pocket containing two stones; one white and one black. And, of course, there is the wrecked slaving ship on the Island called the "Black Rock". We were also introduced early on to the black smoke and the white polar bears, though that may be stretching things a bit.
Side note: My theory is that the two bodies in the cave are going to turn out to be Aaron and Ji-Yeon. We'll see.
The black/white dichotomy has been around since the start of the series. More recent episodes have started implying that Jacob is "white" while "Locke" is "black".
We've been conditioned to think that the guys in the white hats are the good guys while the ones in the black uniforms are the bad guys. That at first looks like the way things are being set up here; Jacob is the good guy and "Locke" is the bad guy. But, is this really correct?
We have seen Jacob manipulating the Losties and the Others for some time. Ben, who thinks he is following Jacob's instructions, has done whatever he has been asked and tells everyone that he and the Others are the "good guys". Of course, the Others have done quite a few not-very-nice things.
Meanwhile, we've seen Smokey the Monster kill quite a few people himself. But, do we know that only "Locke" can become Smokey? Maybe Jacob had that ability too. We still don't know everything here.
Is it possible that "Locke" is really the "good guy" and Jacob the "bad guy"? Or maybe that is too simplistic. Maybe Jacob represents "destiny" and "Locke" represents "free will". That would fit into a lot themes the show has explored as well. Either way, I'm not sure things are as clear cut as they seem to be and I have the feeling that we are going to want to be on "Locke"'s side, not Jacob's.
"Locke" lights a torch and leads Sawyer into the back of the cave. There, the walls and ceiling are covered with names and numbers, most of which have been crossed out. "Locke" points out several that have not been crossed out to Sawyer.
- 4 - Locke
- 8 - Reyes
- 15 - Ford
- 16 - Jarrah
- 23 - Shepherd
- 42 - Kwon
Locke, Hurley, Sawyer, Sayid, Jack and either Jin or Sun. Actually, come to think of it, "Shepherd" could technically be Claire (or even Aaron) and of course "Kwon" could be Ji-Yeon. Given my speculation earlier that "Adam" and "Eve" were Aaron and Ji-Yeon, this could make sense.
More interesting are the names that aren't on the list. The obvious one is Kate's (Austen). She is apparently on the list that Jacob hid inside the ankh that Hurley gave to the Temple people, why isn't her name here? What about the other Losties? (It appears that Claire's name (Littleton) is on the wall but crossed out, though we know she really isn't dead.)
Sawyer asks what the names are all about and "Locke" says that these were people that Jacob had selected to come to the Island. He says that Sawyer must have met Jacob at some point before coming to the Island (and we get a brief flashback to the time when Jacob gave Sawyer a pen at his father's funeral). Sawyer asks about the numbers and "Locke" dismisses them by saying that Jacob was obsessed with numbers.
Hopefully this isn't the final explanation of the Numbers; they've been too key a part of Lost's mythology to dismiss that quickly.
Saywer asks what Jacob brought them there for and "Locke" says that it was so that one of them could take over as protector of the Island. He says they have three choices; do nothing, stay and protect the Island, or leave. Sawyer asks if they can leave and "Locke" says they can leave together. Sawyer says he wants to go.
LOST
"Locke" keeps saying that all he wants to do is leave. So why does he need Sawyer? Can he not leave by himself? Hopefully we will find out more as the season progresses.
2 comments on The Substitute:
I'm happy to read from a fellow goodjer about this show. Nice summary. :)
Thanks for the summary, and great observations.
Leave a Comment:
Offensive, irrelevant, obsolete or just plain annoying comments may be removed at any time without notice.

There seems to be a parallel here to the original timeline; Locke's looking into the spray of water from the sprinklers is very similar to when, on the first day on the Island, he sits outside of shelter seeming to welcome a pouring rain.